The problem with optimism. 

Enjoying this post?

Subscribe to get more free content like this delivered to your inbox.

    I won't spam you. Unsubscribe anytime.

    Picture of Vaughan Broderick
    Vaughan Broderick

    Over the past year, I’ve had several conversations about assumptions. With founders, innovators and people trying to make change happen.

    When I ask, What assumptions are you making? I sometimes get a look that says, What the hell are you talking about?

    Or worse.

    Which is interesting. Because I’m constantly encouraging people to be optimistic. To back themselves. To believe in their ideas.

    But also to think critically.

    And somehow, questioning what we believe can feel like being negative.

    Probably because we become attached to our ideas. We invest time, energy and emotion in them. Sometimes even a little of our identity.

    So when someone questions our assumptions, it can feel like they’re questioning us.

    But here’s the thing.

    We can be wrong about an idea and still make something worthwhile happen.

    Consider two types of optimism:

    Unhelpful optimism – This will work. I know it to be true.

    Helpful optimism – This might work. What would need to be true? Let’s find out.

    Instead of defending our ideas, we become curious about what we don’t yet know. 

    Because an assumption is simply a guess we haven’t checked yet.

    The trouble isn’t making assumptions. We all do. The trouble starts when we mistake them for facts. 

    Perhaps the most optimistic thing we can do is give our ideas a chance to be proven wrong while we still have time to improve them.

    Optimism gives us the courage to begin. But curiosity and a willingness to learn give us a better chance of getting somewhere.

    PS. Innovation in Action provides practical ways to unlock helpful optimism.

    Related Posts:

    [Classic] The 3 Essential Mindsets of Innovation

    Did someone forward this to you? Click here to join 33,189 receiving weekly tips via email and social. The 3 Essential Mindsets of Innovation Read time: 3.75 minutes Welcome to Future-state Thinking, my weekly newsletter where I give actionable content, insights and tools for business and personal growth from my experience as an innovator and entrepreneur. If you’re looking for my Cheat Sheets and Infographic PDFs, the vault is at the bottom of this email! Hi Reader, It’s been 14 years since…

    Read More »

    You Can’t Schedule Your Way Out of a Systems Problem

    Time blocking assumes the problem is a shortage of hours — but creative thinking often needs a different kind of time altogether. Drawing on the hare brain/tortoise mind distinction from Innovation in Action, this piece looks at why reflection and incubation get crowded out by work that proves its value faster, and sets out four conditions — space, psychological safety, broken routines, and the right balance of autonomy and direction — that protect the slower thinking creativity depends on.

    Read More »